This is not a SFW instance. NSFW communities will be tagged, and efforts will be made to keep SFW communities clean, but proceed at your own comfort level.
Oh no, the sun was too much and Mr Fancy Atom had to go to sleep because there was no water for the thirsty guy. Well, better asleep than leaking or blowing up again. Stupid sun throwing all this energy at the ground, so mean.
Airplanes don’t have a bad rep, they are incredibly safe and if one occasionally crashes the death toll is generally limited to the passengers.
My issue with nuclear being presented as perfectly safe is that this is largely theoretical. In practice the list of nuclear and radiation accidents is quite long. If you dig a little into your deaths per terawatt-hour list you can find that they count 433 deaths from Chernobyl. The real death toll remains unknown, but ranges from the 30 officially reported by the Soviet government, the WHO estimate of 4000+, and the 35000 families receiving compensation for “owing to the loss of a breadwinner whose death was deemed to possibly related to the Chernobyl accident.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster)
My point is, each of these nuclear accidents has the potential to kill tens of thousands and cause long-term increases in cancers and birth defects. And despite all the safety claims, we see a major incident about once a decade.
Additionally, we still don’t know where to store the nuclear waste and enriched uranium continues to bring cash to Russia, as we haven’t been able to shake dependance there either.
All in all, nuclear is another fossil fuel that has risks we can’t seem to manage properly and the price is much higher than most renewables. I’m not saying to shut all nuclear plants down immediately, especially if we then have to use coal or gas to make up for the loss in production. But let’s stop praising it as this amazing alternative by making safety and sustainability claims that are based on propaganda numbers.
Reservoir hydro, geothermal and concentrated solar with thermal storage are actually green and could provide base load energy.
You’re free to continue ignoring my points with linked sources in favour of your airplane tangent and theoretical possibilities. As I also said, nuclear sounds all great in theory, but the human factor of cutting corners and prioritising immediate profits are nor giving me the confidence that I’d like to embrace nuclear today.
You shared an opinion piece written by a self-styled “investor” who proceeds to endorse the forthcoming feasibility of fusion. I shared a piece written by one of the authors of the study he is basing his article on. A study published in a peer-reviewed journal and conducted by a reputable university. They are not the same.
As for the date…renewables have only become more viable since 2013. The price has plummeted, and the feasibility of battery storage has skyrocketed.
Ok it’s obvious you’re not here to discuss anything in good faith. You’ve arrived at your conclusion and will make up whatever nonsense you feel like will support it. Have the life you deserve.
One of the things that rarely get mentioned is the way uranium gets mined, almost always next to poor and marginalized people, leaving disease and unlivable places. Something that doesn’t get included In the .gov stats ofcourse. (Ofcourse this is not just a nuclear thing) the way french companies completely ravage places in africa for uranium (and oil) is unacceptable. I’m fairly “meh” on nuclear energy, but it really icks me it is never mentioned.
the current extreme drought in Europe is hopefully a rare occurrence
Lmao no it won’t be, have you been hiding under a rock? You know the climate is completely fucked for us right? Western Europe is one of the fastest heating places even, within a decade or 2 everything south of paris will be just like extremadura.
now that I think about it, do floods have impact on reactor capacities? Like there is a lot more debris and shit in the water.
My intention wasn’t to attack but the “hopefully we won’t have too many droughts” comment while we are on a clear trajectory to a world of +3c flabbergasted me and struck a nerve, I genuinely do not understand how you can make a statement like this, today, if you even have a basic knowledge of anthropic climate change
Also you say this right after you completely misrepresent my argument like I somehow don’t care about the situation of cobalt and lithium mining, which is why I mentioned explicitly it isn’t a solely nuclear issue and that even oil extraction causes huge suffering for anything and anyone in it’s vicinity.
So you try to keep things scientific but it seems to me like you failed and you are just emotionally knee-jerking right now fr.
Oh no, the sun was too much and Mr Fancy Atom had to go to sleep because there was no water for the thirsty guy. Well, better asleep than leaking or blowing up again. Stupid sun throwing all this energy at the ground, so mean.
Removed by mod
Oh boy, do I have news for you.
Removed by mod
Airplanes don’t have a bad rep, they are incredibly safe and if one occasionally crashes the death toll is generally limited to the passengers.
My issue with nuclear being presented as perfectly safe is that this is largely theoretical. In practice the list of nuclear and radiation accidents is quite long. If you dig a little into your deaths per terawatt-hour list you can find that they count 433 deaths from Chernobyl. The real death toll remains unknown, but ranges from the 30 officially reported by the Soviet government, the WHO estimate of 4000+, and the 35000 families receiving compensation for “owing to the loss of a breadwinner whose death was deemed to possibly related to the Chernobyl accident.” (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deaths_due_to_the_Chernobyl_disaster)
My point is, each of these nuclear accidents has the potential to kill tens of thousands and cause long-term increases in cancers and birth defects. And despite all the safety claims, we see a major incident about once a decade.
Additionally, we still don’t know where to store the nuclear waste and enriched uranium continues to bring cash to Russia, as we haven’t been able to shake dependance there either.
All in all, nuclear is another fossil fuel that has risks we can’t seem to manage properly and the price is much higher than most renewables. I’m not saying to shut all nuclear plants down immediately, especially if we then have to use coal or gas to make up for the loss in production. But let’s stop praising it as this amazing alternative by making safety and sustainability claims that are based on propaganda numbers.
Just want to correct it is definitely NOT a fossil fuel.
Unless…
Hahaha, just NUKE IT!! QUICK!! It’s all perfectly safe.
Removed by mod
Reservoir hydro, geothermal and concentrated solar with thermal storage are actually green and could provide base load energy.
You’re free to continue ignoring my points with linked sources in favour of your airplane tangent and theoretical possibilities. As I also said, nuclear sounds all great in theory, but the human factor of cutting corners and prioritising immediate profits are nor giving me the confidence that I’d like to embrace nuclear today.
Removed by mod
Not necessary.
You’d think that some who writes such long arguments for nuclear power would know this.
Removed by mod
You shared an opinion piece written by a self-styled “investor” who proceeds to endorse the forthcoming feasibility of fusion. I shared a piece written by one of the authors of the study he is basing his article on. A study published in a peer-reviewed journal and conducted by a reputable university. They are not the same.
As for the date…renewables have only become more viable since 2013. The price has plummeted, and the feasibility of battery storage has skyrocketed.
Removed by mod
Ok it’s obvious you’re not here to discuss anything in good faith. You’ve arrived at your conclusion and will make up whatever nonsense you feel like will support it. Have the life you deserve.
aaahahahhahahahahahahahaahahahha
I do love your optimism, tho
Removed by mod
One of the things that rarely get mentioned is the way uranium gets mined, almost always next to poor and marginalized people, leaving disease and unlivable places. Something that doesn’t get included In the .gov stats ofcourse. (Ofcourse this is not just a nuclear thing) the way french companies completely ravage places in africa for uranium (and oil) is unacceptable. I’m fairly “meh” on nuclear energy, but it really icks me it is never mentioned.
E.g: french being french monsters exhibit 942331 and there’s plenty of places like that, american navajo comes to mind too.
also weaponry
Lmao no it won’t be, have you been hiding under a rock? You know the climate is completely fucked for us right? Western Europe is one of the fastest heating places even, within a decade or 2 everything south of paris will be just like extremadura.
now that I think about it, do floods have impact on reactor capacities? Like there is a lot more debris and shit in the water.
Removed by mod
My intention wasn’t to attack but the “hopefully we won’t have too many droughts” comment while we are on a clear trajectory to a world of +3c flabbergasted me and struck a nerve, I genuinely do not understand how you can make a statement like this, today, if you even have a basic knowledge of anthropic climate change
Also you say this right after you completely misrepresent my argument like I somehow don’t care about the situation of cobalt and lithium mining, which is why I mentioned explicitly it isn’t a solely nuclear issue and that even oil extraction causes huge suffering for anything and anyone in it’s vicinity. So you try to keep things scientific but it seems to me like you failed and you are just emotionally knee-jerking right now fr.
Removed by mod